Back to Index

Zambia polls: Lessons for Zimbabwe
Zimbabwe Election Support Network
September 29, 2011

The Zimbabwe Election Support Network sent a 15-member mission to observe Zambia's tripartite elections held on September 20 2011.

The objectives of the mission were multi-faceted and included; to observe the Zambian electoral processes and to explore and understand civil society initiatives within and around the electoral process.

Lastly, the mission sought to glean lessons and insights to inform Zimbabweans as they prepare for referendum and the general elections in the future.

Biometric voters' roll

Zambia uses a polling station-based voters' roll with each polling stream having a separate biometric voters' register.

On average the number of voters registered and voting in each polling stream did not exceed 850 which made the voting and counting process more efficient.

The voters' roll included names of people who have been removed from the register and reasons for removal which in some cases were duplications, death and change of residence.

Such information made for increased transparency and inclusivity and provided for a voters' roll which is complete, comprehensive and up-to-date.

Peace campaigns

The mission observed there was a deliberate effort to have a peaceful election and this was evidenced from the many calls for peace from youths and eminent persons such as former President of Zambia, Dr Kenneth Kaunda.

While the atmosphere was peaceful, there were undertones of tension and suspicion of electoral irregularities which marred almost peaceful electoral campaigns.

Peace campaigns mainly targeted the youths, who similar to Zimbabwe, have been used as instruments of violence. The peaceful atmosphere provided room for political parties to campaign though some incidents of violence were experienced during the campaign phase.

People living with disability

While the Electoral Commission of Zambia (ECZ) made efforts to ensure inclusion of people living with disability (PWDs) in electoral processes through the provision of a tactile ballot paper for the visually impaired, this was only limited to the presidential ballot and not to house of assembly and local government.

It is also commendable to note that news broadcasters had a sign language interpreter for hearing impaired as they aired the news.

This increased inclusivity and reduced marginalisation. However, there was need to do more to include the vote of PWDs, such as voter education and improving accessibility of polling stations.

Conflict resolution mechanisms

The ECZ took a proactive role in dealing with conflicts that are inevitable in electoral politics. A pocket-sized manual was published to provide information to citizens and political parties on the mechanisms for resolving electoral conflicts that may arise.

This meant that the commission acknowledged the presence of conflicts and also sought to find ways to resolve them amicably. In addition, a code of conduct signed by political parties was publicised and it was justiciable which reduced impunity.

The role of the security sector in electoral processes

The role of the security sector is defined and the mission observed police were trained on their mandate by the commission before the election and were able to stay within their mandate.

The role of the security sector was to maintain peace and order as well as secure the election and citizens. The role of the military and police remained apolitical and restricted to law and order.

Election results management

While the election was done in a transparent manner and election results for parliamentary and local government elections were announced by returning officers at constituency levels, there were a few hitches with the announcement of presidential results. The delays resulted in agitation and tension which resulted in riots in some areas.

The media

The polarisation of the media in Zambia did not create values of tolerance and peaceful coexistence in society. It was clear that state broadcasters supported the Movement for Multiparty Democracy and the private media were supportive of the opposition political parties. At times some media houses seemed to incite violence which was inimical to a peaceful election.

Transfer of power

Of importance to note was the presence of mechanisms to transfer power in Zambia which is a problematic aspect in Africa where incumbents find it difficult to relinquish power. It is important that mechanisms for transfer of power be provided for to enable a smooth transition to a new dispensation when there is change of government.

Implications for Zimbabwe

A number of lessons can be drawn from Zambia's electoral processes. The need for clean and credible voters' roll that is perceived as comprehensive, up-to-date and complete by all stakeholders, builds confidence in the electorate and all stakeholders.

Politicians and political parties need to preach the message of peace and mean it too. With political will, it is possible to have a peaceful election.

The election management body needs to take proactive measures to address political violence and stem it before it goes out of hand.

A code of conduct for political parties and the media is necessary in environments such as Zimbabwe which are volatile and prone to violence.

The role of the security sector in elections needs to be managed and the security personnel need to stay within their mandate of ensuring law and order as well as peace and not dabbling in politics. Mechanisms for transfer of power need to be in place to ensure change of government.

Elections are contestations for power and as such there is the likelihood of new government taking over, thus power transfer mechanisms should be in place and clear.

Zambia's peaceful election is a demonstration that with political will a peaceful election is possible.

Visit the ZESN fact sheet

Please credit www.kubatana.net if you make use of material from this website. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License unless stated otherwise.

TOP