Back to Index
This article participates on the following special index pages:
Index of results, reports, press stmts and articles on March 31 2005 General Election - post Mar 30
reasons why the legislative elections were "very clearly unfair"
sans frontières/Reporters Without Borders (RSF)
April 05, 2005
Reporters Without Borders today said the
31 March legislative elections in Zimbabwe were "very clearly unfair"
from the press freedom viewpoint, being marred by oppressive legislation,
biased media coverage, almost systematic censorship of dissent and recurrent
violent against critical journalists.
"We have identified at least seven grounds for saying press freedom does
not exist in Zimbabwe in 2005, as in previous years," the organization
"Not only does Zimbabwe have one of Africa's most draconian and authoritarian
press laws but the state media, which are supposed to respect the democratic
criteria established by the Southern Africa Development Community, clearly
opted to provide biased and ill-intentioned coverage," Reporters Without
"Abuse of authority and the repression of dissent are the rule in President
Robert Mugabe's country where, on the very day the elections took place
under the closest surveillance, the police were hounding journalists whose
work irritates the authorities.
Reporters Without Borders added: "In view of the repressive apparatus
contrary to all democratic standards and the prevailing climate for the
independent press that is one of the worst in Africa, the 31 March legislative
election were very clearly unfair."
1. Zimbabwe has had an extremely repressive media law since 2002 called
the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act, which flouts
press freedom principles. It set up a Media and Information Commission
(MIC) which is closely controlled by the government, has the power of
life or death over the independent press, and has banned foreign journalists
from residing in Zimbabwe. Under an amendment approved at the end of 2004,
journalists can be imprisoned for working without MIC accreditation.
2. Coverage of the election campaign by state-owned broadcast and print
media clearly favoured the ruling Zanu-PF party. The Media Monitoring
Project Zimbabwe (MMPZ), a Harare-based independent watchdog, repeatedly
denounced the blatant bias in their reporting of the main opposition party,
the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), and the priority systematically
given to coverage of the ruling party's activities.
3. The Zimbabwean government chose which media were allowed to cover the
legislative elections, arbitrarily excluding a number of major international
news media "guilty" of criticizing the government in the past. Journalists
from the privately-owned South African radio stations Talk Radio 702
and 567 Cape Talk, from the Australian Broadcasting Corporation
(ABC), the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) and several
British newspapers were all refused accreditation.
4. The broadcasts of the privately-owned, London-based SW Radio Africa,
which employs Zimbabwean journalists living in exile, were jammed from
7 March onwards from a military base with the help of Chinese technology.
5. Journalists Toby John Harden and Julian Paul Simmons
of the London-based Sunday Telegraph were arrested near a polling
station 40 km from the capital, Harare, on election day. They were accused
of working without accreditation, and then of having expired tourist visas.
Fredrik Sperling, a journalist with the Swedish public television
broadcaster Sveriges Television (SVT), was also arrested on election
day and expelled after filming at a farm whose owners were evicted and
replaced by a Mugabe relative.
6. Five weeks before the elections, four Zimbabwean journalists working
for different international news media - Cornelius Nduna, Jan
Raath, Tsvangirai Mkwazhi and Angus Shaw - were forced
to go into exile to escape the threat of imminent arrest on a range of
grounds including spying, lack of accreditation and possession of sensitive
7. On 25 February, the MIC ordered the closure of another independent
newspaper, this time one that had only existed for two months. The privately-owned
Weekly Times was based in Bulawayo, the country's second largest city,
and specialized in development issues. Its first issue included an interview
with Bishop Pius Ncube of Bulawayo in which he criticized Mugabe's failure
to repent for the massacre of 20,000 innocent civilians in Gukurahundi
in the 1980s. It was the fourth independent newspaper to be closed for
political reasons in less than two years, following the Daily News
(Zimbabwe's most widely read daily), the Daily News On Sunday and
The Tribune. Despite a supreme court ruling on 14 March authorizing
the Daily News to resume publishing, the MIC has still not responded
to its request to register, and no newspaper can operate without being
Bureau Afrique /
Reporters sans frontières / Reporters Without Borders
5, rue Geoffroy-Marie
75009 Paris, France
Tel : (33) 1 44 83 84 84
Fax : (33) 1 45 23 11 51
Email : email@example.com
Web : www.rsf.org
Please credit www.kubatana.net if you make use of material from this website.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License unless stated otherwise.