| |
Back to Index
SADC
Mauritius protocol: Assessment of compliance with the protocol -
Issue No. 11
Sokwanele
January 10, 2005
On 17 August
2004, SADC leaders meeting in Mauritius adopted the SADC Protocol
– Principles and Guidelines Governing Democratic Elections. Zimbabwe,
as a member of SADC, also signed the Protocol and committed itself
to implementing its standards.
"Mauritius
Watch" provides a regular, objective and non-partisan assessment
of Zimbabwe’s compliance with the Protocol. In the run-up to the
2005 Parliamentary Elections we note any significant failures to
adhere to the SADC standards.
|
Date
|
Incidents/Developments
|
SADC
standards breached
|
|
06.01.05
|
TOP
MARKS FOR MUZZLING THE PRESS
Zimbabwe
is rated among the three countries in the world with the worst
media laws meant to stifle press freedom, according to the
World Association of Newspapers (WAN).
In its
press freedom report for 2004, the Paris-based WAN said the
worst attempts to create legal barriers for journalists were
seen in the Islamic republic of Iran, the former Soviet Union
republic of Uzbekistan and crisis-torn Zimbabwe.
The WAN
report reads in part: "Serious limitations of freedom
of expression in the form of national security laws, terrorism
acts and criminal defamation laws have landed scores of journalists
in prison and resigned many more to practising self-censorship.
"The
most audacious attempts to create legal barriers to stifle
the press can be seen in Uzbekistan, Iran and Zimbabwe."
In the
last few days Robert Mugabe has signed into law amendments
to the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act
(AIPPA), which add further controls and criminal sanctions
to an already draconian piece of legislation. Journalists
can now be jailed for two years for practising without a licence,
while media companies can be closed and have assets seized
for operating without being registered.
Hundreds
of journalists have been arrested in the past two years while
three newspapers, including the country’s only independent
and biggest circulating daily newspaper, the Daily News, were
shut down for breaching the harsh Press laws.
(See the
report in Zim Online: www.zimonline.co.za
)
|
2.1.5
Equal opportunity for all political parties to access the
state media
4.1.2
Conducive environment for free, fair and peaceful elections
7.4 (Government
to) safeguard the human and civil liberties of all citizens
including the freedom of movement, assembly, association,
expression, and campaigning as well as access to the
media on the part of all stakeholders, during the electoral
process …
|
|
09.01.05
|
STATE
MEDIA PROPAGATING HATRED
The Zimbabwe
Broadcasting Holdings (ZBH), the country’s sole broadcaster,
together with the dominant government controlled newspaper
group, Zimpapers, continue to engage in a disinformation campaign
in which they regularly propagate hatred and disaffection
against government critics.
Dumisani
Gandhi, an advocacy officer with the Media Monitoring Project
Zimbabwe (MMPZ) spoke recently at a human rights workshop
in Gweru. Gandhi said that according to MMPZ findings, the
prime targets of hate speech were the main opposition party,
the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), civic groups, whites
and individuals including journalists. He added that such
language could be a recipe for civil strife in the highly
polarized political environment of Zimbabwe.
Gandhi
cited recent examples of hate speech by Nathaniel Manheru,
the Herald columnist, who described the MDC as a "many
headed monster whose every limb carries its patenting scales
and trait of treachery". The same columnist described
the outspoken Roman Catholic Archbishop Pius Ncube as "the
man who wore a face filled with hate but not divine hate,
but of a common villager struck with spiteful jealousy … and
when raw hate darts out it is seasoned with a bit (of) raw,
uncooked saliva…The best medicine is to ignore the idiot,
to leave him to wallow in his un-catholic hate …"
(See the
report in The Standard: http://www.thestandard.co.zw/)
|
2.1.3
Political tolerance
2.1.5
Equal opportunity for all political parties to access the
state media
4.1.1
Constitutional and legal guarantees of freedom and rights
of the citizens
4.1.2
Conducive environment for free, fair and peaceful elections
7.4. (Government
to) safeguard the human and civil liberties of all citizens
including the freedom of movement, assembly, association,
expression and campaigning … during the electoral process
…
|
|
08.01.05
|
MILITIA
BROUGHT IN AHEAD OF ELECTION
The regime
of Robert Mugabe plans to incorporate more than
20 000
of its controversial youth militias into the police force
ahead of March’s parliamentary election.
The recruitment
of the youths, accused by churches and human rights groups
of committing violence and terrorizing opponents of the ruling
ZANU PF party, will double up police manpower which at present
stands at about 21 000 officers. According to police sources
the recruitment is due to be completed by the end of February,
just ahead of the poll.
"Initially
there were concerns of indiscipline among untrained reserves
but the highest authorities sanctioned the move (because)
we are racing against time. It takes six months to train a
regular policeman and the election is just around the corner,"
said a senior police officer who did not want to be named.
On September
5 2003, Solidarity Peace Trust published a detailed report
entitled "Shaping youths in a truly Zimbabwean manner".
In it they carefully chronicled some of the abuses perpetrated
by the youth militia on perceived opponents of ZANU PF and
the abuses to which youths in training, especially young girls,
were subjected by the national youth service training programme.
The report noted that the youths were subjected to political
indoctrination and were brutalized by violence.
The report
states that "Conditions in the training camps are confirmed
to be severe; particularly in the first year of implementation,
rampant sexual activity among youth militia themselves was
widely reported. Female youth militia have reported rape on
a systematic basis in some camps, involving girls as young
as 11 years of age.
"Youth
militia pregnancies, and sexually transmitted infections including
HIV, have been reported as resulting from youth militia training
experiences from a variety of sources in the last two years.
Camp instructors are commonly implicated as among the rapists."
(See the
report 0n Zim Online; www.zimonline.co.za)
(To read
the Solidarity Peace Trust Report log on to their website,
www.solidaritypeacetrust.org.za)
|
2.1.3
Political tolerance
4.1.1.
Constitutional and legal guarantees of freedom and rights
of the citizens
4.1.2
Conducive environment for free, fair and peaceful elections
7.5 (Government
to) take all necessary measures and precautions to prevent
the perpetration of fraud, rigging or any other illegal practices
throughout the whole electoral process, in order to maintain
peace and security
7.7 (Government
to) ensure that adequate security is provided to all parties
participating in the elections
|
|
03.01.05
|
ZANU
PF BUYS INFLUENCE WITH CHIEFS
In a bid
to secure their compliance with the ruling party, the ZANU
PF regime of Robert Mugabe has purchased brand new Mazda B
1800 trucks for Zimbabwe’s traditional leaders, the chiefs.
Now the regime plans to give them wide ranging legal powers,
a move seen as giving them more power to punish those who
support the opposition.
In October
last year Local Government minister Ignatius Chombo announced
the upgrading of chiefs’ status, giving them powers to preside
over cases with a monetary value up to Z$ 100 million. (Roughly
equivalent to USD 17,400 or Rand 105,000 – a huge sum in impoverished
rural Zimbabwe)
In reporting
on these moves SW Radio Africa, an independent news service
which broadcasts from London, commented: "With elections
just around the corner the ruling party is going all out to
make them (the chiefs) not only comfortable but powerful."
Their report cited the example of Chief Tedious Matambanashe
from the Uzumba-Maramba-Pfungwe district of Mashonaland East,
who banished a family of eight because of reports they were
opposition supporters.
The same
incident was reported in the Zimbabwe Independent (January
7). And there have been numerous other recent examples of
ZANU PF using the traditional leaders to intimidate the rural
population so that they are too afraid to support the opposition
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party.
Previous
elections have been punctuated with promises of telephone
lines, cell phones and a secretary each for the chiefs, while
tarred roads were laid down to their homesteads.
(Reported
on SW Radio Africa - http://www.swradioafrica.com/)
(See
also the report in the Zimbabwe Independent; www.theindependent.co.zw)
|
4.1.2
Conducive environment for free, fair and peaceful elections
7.4
(Government to) safeguard the human and civil liberties of
all citizens including the freedom of movement,
assembly, association, expression and campaigning …
7.5 (Government
to) take all necessary measures and precautions to prevent
the perpetration of fraud, rigging or any other illegal
practices throughout the whole electoral process …
|
|
09.01.05
|
RURAL
TEACHERS FEAR VIOLENCE IN POLL Scores of teachers last week
converged on the offices of the Ministry of Education, Sport
and Culture in Mutare, seeking transfers from rural schools
to urban and peri-urban stations.
Nearly
100 teachers were seeking urgent transfers, citing transport
costs and the fear of potential violence in the forthcoming
election as their reason for doing so.
In the
2000 parliamentary election and the 2002 presidential elections
teachers were targeted for violence mainly by ruling party
activists, including so-called war veterans. They were accused
of supporting or being sympathetic to the popular opposition
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party. Some of them were
harassed, beaten up and forced to flee their rural schools.
Shortly
before the presidential election in 2002, 30 schools around
the country were closed by ZANU PF supporters. Stan Mudenge,
the Foreign Minister, told a teachers’ meeting: "You
can even be killed for supporting the opposition."
(Reported
in The Standard: http://www.thestandard.co.zw/)
|
2.1.2
Freedom of association
2.1.3
Political tolerance
4.1.1
Constitutional and legal guarantees of freedom and rights
of the citizens
4.1.2
Conducive environment for free, fair and peaceful elections
7.7(Government
to) ensure that adequate security is provided to all parties
participating in the elections
|
|
03.01.05
|
REPORT
ON POLITICAL VIOLENCE
The main
opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party has
produced through its Information and Publicity Department,
a detailed report on the human rights abuses suffered by its
supporters and officials at the hands of ZANU PF supporters,
youth militia, state agents and war veterans. In the report,
which covers the year 2004, the incidents are set out in chronological
order. Some of these incidents will be cited in the next issue
of Mauritius Watch.
(The MDC
Report can be viewed on www.mdczimbabwe.org)
|
|
Note: The fraudulent
and violence-ridden elections of 2000 and 2002 were narrowly "won"
by Robert Mugabe, who has maintained his iron grip on the country
by using strategies designed to annihilate all forms of opposition.
Although a date
has not been given yet for the Parliamentary Elections which Mugabe
has indicated will take place some time in March, already it can
be seen that there is no prospect that those elections will be fair
and free. During the eleven weeks that Sokwanele has been systematically
tracking and recording developments, it has become increasingly
apparent that the regime is moving further away from the
SADC Protocol on Democratic Elections, rather than towards compliance.
The regime is going to some lengths within the region to portray
itself as moving to meet those criteria, but the reality is totally
different. Behind the façade of democracy, every institution
or legal principle which would favour a free and fair election,
has been systematically destroyed to ensure that the poll will produce
a pre-determined result favouring the ruling party.
Please credit www.kubatana.net if you make use of material from this website.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License unless stated otherwise.
TOP
|